Thursday, May 23, 2013

Changes Coming to Champions League Qualification


There's a fascinating piece on ESPNFC today about some rule changes to the UEFA Champions League process that will likely take place in the coming years.  Most of it is coming about as UEFA seeks to strengthen the Europa League by offering a new incentive to win it.

According to ESPN's Dale Johnson, on Friday UEFA will announce that the winners of the Europa League will qualify for the next season's Champion's League.  This comes as a result of the fact that many of the bigger UEFA countries don't seem to lake the Europa League seriously.  Michael Platini has openly criticized France's attitude, and as Johnson points out, Italy hasn't placed a Europa League finalist since 1999.  So the reasoning is, give these clubs the carrot on a stick of Champion's League qualification and they'll push harder to win the tournament.  Will it work?  I guess we'll find out.

UEFA is also considering allowing 5 teams from the same FA into the Champions League instead of the current max of four, currently awarded to England, Spain, and Germany.  Italy used to get four, but lost their fourth slot to Germany a couple of years ago as Germany's success in European competitions has soared.  Obviously a lot of the minnows will be pretty unhappy about this, and if it happens, it remains to be seen if they will add more teams or just rework the current allocation.

This leaves a lot of permutations to discuss about league positioning, who finishes in the top four or five versus who won what competition and such.  I'll refer the interested reader to Johnson's article as he does a great job discussing scenarios and various loopholes in UCL history.

Personally I would welcome the addition of the Europa League winner to the Champions League.  I'm very glad that Chelsea took the competition seriously this year.  Sometimes the promise of more hardware isn't quite enough for a big club to play for when they're chasing the huge payday of a Champion's League spot in the league table.  This could offer more roads for the clubs that might feel stuck in the middle.

The Champions League rules and qualification procedures run in a three year cycle, which means the first Europa League winner that would qualify for the Champions League would be whoever wins the 2015 Final in Warsaw.

Wednesday, May 22, 2013

MLS Clubs Learn US Open Cup Fate



The second round of the 2013 US Open Cup was played at sites around the country Tuesday night, which means that with those results in tow, the US based Major League Soccer clubs know who their third round opponents will be and where they will play.  It's a little different this year, as clubs won't be allowed to purchase the home game from their opponents.  That didn't work too well for RSL last year, as NASL side Minnesota sold their home game to the Claret and Cobalt, then proceed to stomp them at Rio Tinto stadium.  Here's a look at the MLS sides and their opponents with games to be played May 28 and May 29.  Home team listed first.

May 28, 2013:


  • May 28: Richmond Kickers (USL PRO) vs. D.C. United (MLS), 7 pm ET
  • May 28: Philadelphia Union (MLS) vs. Ocean City Nor'easters (PDL), 7:30 pm ET
  • May 28: Orlando City SC (USL PRO) vs. Colorado Rapids (MLS), 7: 30 pm ET
  • May 28: Fort Lauderdale Strikers (NASL) vs. FC Dallas (MLS), 7:30 pm ET
  • May 28: Charleston Battery (USL PRO) vs. San Jose Earthquakes (MLS), 7:30 pm ET
  • May 28: Rochester Rhinos (USL PRO) vs. New England Revolution (MLS), 7:35 pm ET
  • May 28: Sporting Kansas City (MLS) vs. Des Moines Menace (PDL), 8:30 pm ET
  • May 28: Real Salt Lake (MLS) vs. Atlanta Silverbacks (NASL), 9:30 pm ET
  • May 28: LA Blues (USL PRO) vs. Chivas USA (MLS), 10:30 pm ET

May 29, 2013:



  • May 29: Charlotte Eagles (USL PRO) vs. Chicago Fire (MLS), 7 pm ET
  • May 29: Carolina RailHawks (NASL) vs. LA Galaxy (MLS), 7:15 pm ET
  • May 29: Columbus Crew (MLS) vs. Dayton Dutch Lions (USL PRO), 7:30 pm ET
  • May 29: New York Red Bulls (MLS) vs. Reading United AC (PDL), 7:30 pm ET
  • May 29: Tampa Bay Rowdies (NASL) vs. Seattle Sounders (MLS), 7:30 pm ET
  • May 29: Houston Dynamo (MLS) vs. FC Tucson (PDL), 8:30 pm ET
  • May 29: Portland Timbers (MLS) vs. Wilmington Hammerheads (USL PRO), 10:30 pm ET
 Anybody spot any trendy upset picks?  It can be hard to come by good coverage of lower division soccer in the US, but don't count NASL sides out especially.  USL PRO sides and PDL sides have been known to pull an upset or two as well.  RSL vs the Atlanta Silverbacks will be a trendy pick I think, given RSL's stumbles in the tourney and Eric Wynalda's involvement with the Silverbacks.  I also suspect the Chicago Fire might have a tough time with the Charlotte Eagles, being at Charlotte.  The Richmond Kickers host DC United, and they usually do well in this tournament.  Pair that with DC's recent struggles and there is a recipe for a giant killing.

Check out the matches next week at your home stadium.  Most MLS sides try to make a streaming option available, but please go out and support your club in this historic tournament.  After all, a CCL place is on the line for the winner.

Tony Pulis Out at Stoke City

Manager Tony Pulis has left Stoke City (bbc.co.uk)

The EPL "silly season" is about to hit high gear now that the season is officially over.  Manchester City didn't wait for the season to be over to sack Roberto Mancini, and Stoke City's Tony Pulis is now the next man booted off of the managerial carousel.  The club announced on Monday that Pulis and Stoke were parting ways by mutual consent.

There's good and bad with Tony Pulis.  First off, he's never been relegated as a manager.  In his years at Stoke, he brought them up to the Premier League and kept them there for the last five.  Plus, you usually didn't see Stoke down fighting the relegation battles near the bottom three either, though it was close this year.  An away trip to Stoke was always a tough three points, even for the Premier League's big clubs.  A draw was considered fairly standard.

His club's style has been the sticking point.  Offensively, Stoke have been known to get their midfield to just lob balls over the top to their strikers, with little or no variation to this "direct approach."  Defensively, they've been hard nosed and relatively tough to score against, but their offensive approach yielded little in the way of goals, creating many draws.  Pulis only won 29% of his matches at Stoke.

Stoke have been a pretty solid mid-table bet, but they've shown little progress, either in moving up the table or changing their style of play to facilitate that move.  Of interest to American fans, Pulis brought two MLS men to Stoke: Houston's Geoff Cameron and Brek Shea of FC Dallas.  Cameron has gotten some time, enough to be in the US National Team mix.  Shea has had a tougher go of it, failing to crack the 18 most weekends.

No word yet on where Pulis will end up. It's hard to see him being considered for one of the bigger EPL openings, say Everton or City.  I could see him ending up in a Harry Redknapp type situation, where a club struggling in the bottom three in the middle of the season tries to bring him in to help them avoid relegation, we'll see.

There hasn't been much speculation as of yet about Stoke's vacancy.  The AP is suggesting Everton's Phil Neville, who is retiring, or Brighton's Gus Poyet.  Sky Sports has been focusing largely on former QPR boss Mark Hughes and Roberto Di Matteo, who guided Chelsea to UEFA Champion's League title as interim boss last season.

Tuesday, May 21, 2013

Opinion: MLS Formally Announces NY2, One Fan's Thoughts.

MLS has formally announced that NYC will be the home of it's 20th franchise.

Major League Soccer and Commissioner Don Garber made it official this morning, New York City will be the home of the league's next expansion franchise.  The team, currently operating under the name "New York City FC" will be a jointly run venture owned by Manchester City in England and the New York Yankees.  They are scheduled to begin play in 2015, and currently have no concrete stadium plans.

So there's the news portion of this entry, the rest is strictly opinion, and some folks at MLS aren't going to like it.  Now keep in mind, I'm not a businessman, nor am I a New Yorker, so I don't pretend to be an authority on the issues that are involved here.  What I am is a die hard MLS fan who pumps hundreds of my own dollars into my club and the league every year, and I believe that people like me should have a voice in the process.  However, all the concerns raised by any number of fans or fan blogs have poo-pooed by the league, if they are even acknowledged at all.  There are quite a few MLS fans, and potential MLS fans in other markets, that really feel railroaded by this whole process.  If you don't believe me, take a look at twitter.  The American soccer media has been running interference for the League on this all day, hald-assedly answering legitimate questions or just plain saying we have no idea what we're talking about, after all, this is NEW YORK baby!

Now I don't have an objection to New York City having an expansion franchise.    It's true that all of the "major sports leagues" in the USA have a presence in/around NYC.  I do have an issue with the timing.  There are other markets that really are begging for MLS (Orlando) who at least have a temporary stadium in place, again, Orlando could play in the Citrus Bowl.  It would be no worse than DC United playing at RFK.  I'll also give MLS credit for not bowing to the Cosmos ownership group.  The Cosmos are a brand, period, and bringing in a team just for the the brand is even worse than what they're doing.

This issue with a potential stadium in New York really bothers me.  The Yankees participation in the project means that Yankee Stadium MIGHT be an option for a temporary site, but it's nothing but a stop gap measure.  Garber has pursuing a plan to put a stadium on Flushing Meadows park land in Queens, but has met with heavy resistance from the locals, who don't really feel like giving up the park space that they already have.  This has caused major issues, and by Garber's own admission, there is no plan B at this point.  This is perhaps the biggest sticking point, and I'm sure the league and the new ownership group think that all they have to do is throw money at it and the problem will go away.  I'm not sure that's going to be the case.  

Plus, how does this affect the Red Bulls?  Take a look at least weekend's nationally broadcast match between the Red Bulls and the LA Galaxy at Red Bull Arena.  The Galaxy practically sell out every stadium, even without Beckham, yet the Red Bull logo in the stands was plainly visible between the sparse crowd of folks in attendance.  Fact: the Red Bulls seem incapable of filling their stadium, despite the presence of world class players like Thierry Henry and Tim Cahill.  Don't give me that "but they're all the way out in New Jersey" thing either.  People drive to New Jersey to see Jets and the Giants at the Meadowlands, correct?    Plus, we drive 45 minutes to an hour to see Real Salt Lake every match too, and we're season ticket holders.  Obviously SLC traffic is a whole different ball game than getting from NY to Jersey, but if people want the product badly enough, they'll go, hence the NFL situation.  Plus what chance will the Red Bulls have of continuing to attract world class talent with the rich step-brother next door?

It seems to me that most of this is based on TV money, and I'm not sure the MLS TV model is on the right road.  Almost every Red Bulls match is broadcast on either ESPN or NBC Sports, yet the league's ratings continue to be horridly underwhelming.  Plus, the league continues to shove matches like Chicago vs Philadelphia at us because of the large market thinking.  These matches tend to be total snoozers because the league's best soccer is not played in Chicago or Philadelphia, though the Union seem to be heading in the right direction and have an outstanding stadium and fanbase, so no  offense.  The ratings seem to show that the large market bias isn't working particularly well for MLS.  What can be assured is this: the New York/LA centric MLS TV coverage is just going to get worse with this development.  

In the final analysis, I'm not sure this is the best move to grow the league in the long term.  It's a money grab, period.  MLS will get 60 million more in an expansion fee from this franchise than they would get from an Orlando market or elsewhere.  Money talks, and the execs listen.  They don't listen to the fans though.  They don't listen to the fans who have already said they don't give a hoot about New York games on TV.  They don't listen to fans who say they don't want one of the league's flagship franchises to be a farm team for a free wheeling EPL club.  They don't listen to fans from other markets who are literally crying out for this sport.  Now, if they are going to expand further, they're going over FIFA's 20 team limit, not that MLS has ever cared about anything FIFA does, which costs teams their best players every time an international date rolls around.

They're going to do what they're going to do, end of story.  I'm not saying it isn't going to work.  I love MLS, and for the sake of the league, I really hope they know what they're doing.  I'm just not sure that a venture between a bunch of oil rich dudes and the baseball team that kept firing and rehiring Billy Martin over and over again is the best idea in the world when competitive football already exists in other markets.

Just my two cents.

Monday, May 20, 2013

EPL Final Sunday 2013: Chelsea, Arsenal Clinch UCL spots.

Demba Ba and Chelsea clinched 3rd place with a win over Everton (Getty Images)

Today was the last day of the 2012-2013 EPL season.  It's always sad to see the league wrap up another campaign, and it's bittersweet for some people this year as retirements and changes in TV contract rights will really change how we, here in the US, see the league next year.  More on that later, let's talk about today's pertinent action.

Often the final Sunday is called "Survival Sunday" as teams scrap to escape relegation.  That wasn't the case this year.  QPR and Reading have been relegated for a few weeks now, and Wigan joined them with a loss to Arsenal last Tuesday.  Last year we fans were spoiled as the EPL title came down to pretty much the last kick of the season as Manchester City came from behind to steal the title from United.  This year, the Red Devils put that to rest weeks ago. 

That doesn't mean that there wasn't anything to play for today though.  There was a lot of pride and a lot of MONEY on the line as three teams, Chelsea, Arsenal, and Tottenham battled for the final two UEFA Champions League places.  Chelsea were pretty much through, but Spurs needed a win and some help from the Gunners to climb into fourth.  The Gunners had qualified for the Champions League every year under Arsene Wenger, and were keen to keep that streak alive.  There was also the possibility of Chelsea and Arsenal having a one game playoff to decide 3rd place, as they were so close on both points and goal difference.  In the end, that wasn't needed.

All Chelsea needed to do to avoid that fate was win.  That wasn't going to be an easy task as they hosted Everton, who were playing their last match with David Moyes in charge.  Juan Mata gave the Blues the lead on 7 minutes, but Everton bounced back later with a goal from Steven Naismith in minute 14.  The game remained deadlocked late, with the specter of the playoff hanging over Stamford Bridge.  Then Fernando Torres punched in a goal in minute 76 to cement the newly minted Europa League Winners in third place.

Third place is important because the winner goes straight to the Champions League group stage, and Arsenal were shooting for that as well as just trying to hold off a late charge from Tottenham into fourth.  The Gunners visited Sports Direct Arena to face a lowly Newcastle squad who had every reason to already be on the golf course.  Newcastle did put up a fight though, and played better than they have of late.  It wasn't enough though as Laurent Koscielny scored in the 55th minute to give the Gunners the only goal they would need on the day.

All of Sunday's matches ran concurrently though, so with the matches being close, tension was still high.  Spurs needed the three points against Sunderland to even have a prayer at joining the Champions League, plus they needed Arsenal to lose or draw.  Spurs left it late as Gareth Bale hit a wonder strike to give them a 1-0 win at White Heart Lane, however with Arsenal's win, the Spurs face another season in the the gauntlet that is the Europa League.

So here's how things shape up now that all is said and done:

Champions League Group Stage--
Manchester United (Champions)
Manchester City
Chelsea

Champions League Playoff Qualification--
Arsenal

Europa League--
Swansea City (League Cup Champions)
Wigan (FA Cup Champions)
Tottenham Hotspur (5th Place Finish in the Premier League)

Relegation:
Wigan
Reading (promoted this year)
Queens Park Rangers (QPR finish in last place).

Promoted to EPL:
Cardiff City (Championship winners)
Hull City (Championship Runner-up)
Watford OR Crystal Palace (TBD by playoff at Wembley on 27 May).

So there it is folks.  Congrats again to United and Sir Alex on a great career.

Next year fans in the USA will being seeing the league covered by a different network for the first time in a long time.  NBC Sports was awarded the broadcast rights earlier this year in a move that was a big blow to the current holders: Fox Soccer and ESPN.  I'll miss Ian Darke's call on ESPN, but I'm very glad Gus Johnson won't be torturing any more Premier League matches on Fox.

Check back later this week for the Puddle's season review, and don't forget, only 90 days til next year!

Wednesday, May 15, 2013

QPR Man Arrested, Suspected of Rape

QPR Striker Loic Remy has been arrested on suspicion of rape in London.

This is some more of that kind of off-the-pitch news that football fans, and really human beings in general hate to see, yet here it is.  QPR striker Loic Remy has been arrested in London and is being held on charges of rape according to reports from various sources including Sky Sports News. 

If these allegations are true, they'll turn out to be particularly heinous.  The alleged victim, 34, claims she visited Remy at his apartment in Fulham on May 6.  Remy, his cousin, and a friend were said to be present.  The woman claims that she was given a drink and then passed out, only to awaken hours later and find that she had been raped by all three men. 

Pretty horrendous allegations.

A spokesman for the London Metropolitan Police confirmed that three men aged 26, 23, and 22 were arrested in connection with the allegations at a Fulham residence and are still being detained at a West London Police Station.  Sapphire, the MPS unit in charge of sexual assualt cases is investigating the case.

For their part, QPR released a statement saying they were aware of the allegations concerning Remy, but would not comment at this time due to the active police investigation.  Remy is a French international who joined QPR in the last transfer window.  Despite his personal success, Rangers were not able to hold off relegation from the Premier League.  Several clubs were reportedly interested in obtaining his services.

What does one say about this kind of thing?  For one, you don't want to throw Remy to the wolves without a fair trial.  He's not automatically guilty because he's a pro footballer.  On the other hand, the allegations need to be taken seriously and investigated fully.  He shouldn't be able to dodge it just because he's a pro footballer either.  In the end, you just hope the truth comes out, and if he is guilty, he should face the maximum sentence and his career should be over.  We'll have to wait and see, but for sure it's one headache QPR didn't need.

Also check out the EPL Talk article about the incident here.

Monday, May 13, 2013

Congratulations to Wigan Athletic, 2012-2013 FA Cup Champions!

Wigan Coach Roberto Martinez and Chairman Dave Whelan with the FA Cup (Lee Smith/Action Images)

Congratulations are in order for Wigan Athletic, who won their first ever major title on Saturday with an improbable FA Cup Final victory over a Premier League giant at Wembley.  The Latics stunned Manchester City 1-0 with a goal from Ben Watson right at the end of the match, leaving City, who were also down a man, with pretty much no time to push for an equalizer.

It was, one thinks, the perfect Wigan victory.  They were by far the more positive of the two sides all match long, playing football in their methodical fashion while City looked sluggish.  Honestly, despite the fact that there was a major trophy on the line, City looked as though they had already checked out to the beach or to the golf course for the summer, and Wigan took their one, best chance.

Check out Watson's stunning header as City stand around with their zonal marking:

The celebrations might be short lived for Wigan however, as they face a tough road to avoid relegation from the Barclay's Premier League. They have to win both of their final matches against Arsenal at the Emirates on Tuesday and at home against fellow relegation battlers Aston Villa on Sunday. To add to the difficulty of Tuesday, the match is pretty much a must win for Arsenal to qualify for the Champions League next season. The Gunners will be well rested and motivated. But whatever happens in the Premier League, Wigan deserve credit for creating one of the FA Cup's most memorable moments, and keeping the romance or the tournament alive and well. I'll be hoping they can hang on to the Premier League spot as well.

Fenerbahce Fan Murdered After Turkish Derby

Fenerbahce fan Burak Yildirim (left) was killed after the derby with Galatasaray (Photo: Cihan, Ozgur Gunes)

There's been some very sad news out of Istanbul this morning following this weekend's derby clash between Fenerbahce and Galatasaray, which Fenerbahce won 2-1.  A 20 year old Fenerbahce fan, Burak Yildirim, was stabbed to death at a bus stop while returning home after the match.

According to Anadolu Agency, Turkey's state-run news agency, Yildirim, who was wearing a Fenerbahce shirt, was stabbed in the heart by two individuals in Galatasaray garb.  He was taken immediately to Bezmialem Vakif University Hospital, but died shortly thereafter despite medical efforts.  Anadolu suggests that Police have CCTV footage of the attack and are pursuing those responsible after identifying them.  Other sources say that the assailants remain unknown at this time.

Fenerbahce released a statement on it's website expressing condolences to Yildirim's family.  Turkish Minister of Youth and Sports, Suat Kılıç, stated on his Twitter feed that he the killers will be captured soon, he also that  “The death of one person is the death of all humanity."

The Puddle expresses heartfelt condolences to the family and friends of Mr. Yildirim and the entire Fenerbahce fan community.  Hopefully the Turkish police will able to quickly track down the people responsible for this.  Supporting your club should not be a death sentence just because some criminals choose to masquerade as fans and perpetrate violence in the name of football. 

Sunday, May 12, 2013

Goats vs Ball Boys. Who Ya Got?

Chivas USA's Mario de Luna (center) will get a call from the Disciplinary Committee (AP Photo)

There isn't much going well for Chivas USA these days.  Despite the strong start to the season under Chelis as coach, they find themselves on the bottom of a stacked Western Conference, three points back of their LA neighbors the Galaxy for the final playoff spot.  Their situation was made worse on Sunday when they took a 3-0 thrashing at the hands of the Portland Timbers at Jeld-Wen Field.

Unfortunately for the Goats, matters became even worse late on as frustrations started to boil over.  Defender Mario de Luna shoved a Portland ball boy when the ball boy refused to give him the ball, for a Portland throw-in.  Anecdotes from folks who were at the stadium vary, but some reports are even saying that the 4th official instructed the ball boy not to give the ball to de Luna, as it was a Portland throw.  It would be hard to argue that the ball boy was obstructing a restart, since it was a Portland throw.  However, it should be said that any altercation with a ball boy is unacceptable. Period.  Ask Eden Hazard of Chelsea, who was trashed for a ball boy incident even after the Swansea ball boy admitted that he was trying to obstruct play in favor of his team.

I, for one, am getting tired of this nonsense that crops up every once in awhile.  There's just no need for it.  I don't care if the ball boy is a kid or a teenager, there's no reason for an adult, de Luna, Hazard, or Colin Clark, to get into an altercation over this.  If there's a problem, the player needs to bring it to the attention of the referee, not shove or kick the ball boy.  Be an adult, an realize that the cameras are indeed rolling.

I watch a ton of MLS, practically every match over the course of the week with MLS Live, and thankfully, these incidents are far from the norm.  However, MLS should come down harshly on these guys.  Maybe a bit more time needs to be spent training the ball boys too.  I've seen plenty of clueless ball kids at RSL matches.  I don't think I've ever seen one try to obstruct play intentionally, but there have been a few who just don't seem to have their head in what they're doing.

In this particular incident, the ball boy wasn't hurt.  Chelis also checked with the ball boy to make sure he was ok, which is nice.  Still hopefully the league will take some action so this particular black eye on the game goes away completely.  There's just no reason for it.  I get that late in a match tensions run high, but again, you're supposed to be an adult, make the right decision. 

De Luna was given a yellow card on the play and will now miss Chivas USA's next match against Real Salt Lake next Sunday.

Wednesday, May 8, 2013

49 Trophies, 1 Icon: Sir Alex Ferguson

Guardian.co.uk

This is not really news at this point.  If you're a football fan and you haven't known that Sir Alex is retiring for some hours, you've probably been comfortably living under a rock.  Rumors started to circulate overnight in the UK, and Manchester United confirmed it on the club's website this morning.  For the first time since 1986, the Red Devils will be looking for a new manager.
The internet, blogs, and social media have experienced an outpouring of gratitude for Ferguson from United fans and non United fans.  I am of the latter group, but honestly, there's not much more to be said that hasn't been said in the 47575858437854836758474 articles and blog entries that have hit in the last few hours.

Let me approach it this way.  Sir Alex Ferguson took over Manchester United when I was 8 years old.  My knowledge of English football was confined to the stories that my grandfather would tell of Chelsea and the London clubs from his days in Europe after the war.  Since I have been aware of professional football, Sir Alex HAS BEEN Manchester United.  There aren't too many managers in pro football that can say that their identity is so wrapped up in their club.  Perhaps Arsene Wenger is halfway there at Arsenal.  Stateside, Jason Kreis MIGHT BE in the infancy of such a time at RSL, but I don't think there will ever be another manager/club relationship like Sir Alex and Manchester United.

If I took the space to list all of Ferguson's accomplishments, we'd be here all day.  Suffice it say between 1976 and 2013 Sir Alex has won 49 trophies between St. Mirren, Aberdeen, and Manchester United.  These titles include the Scottish Premier Division, the Scottish Cup, The Scottish League Cup, The Barclay's Premier League, The FA Cup, the League Cup. The UEFA Champions League, and the FIFA Club World Cup.

His awards as manager as numerous, including a couple of different "Manager of the Decade" awards.  He received the Officer of the Order of the British Empire (OBE) in 1983.  In 1995 he was named Commander of the Order of the British Empire (CBE).  He was also made Knight Bachelor in 1999.

Sir Alex will give way at the end of the season, his last match in charge being against West Brom.  He will stay on at United, stepping into the board room where he hopes to still shape the future of the club.  Speculation on his replacement is revolving around David Moyes, who is out of contract at Everton, and Jose Mourinho, who is leaving Real Madrid this summer.

The Puddle congratulates Sir Alex on a wonderful career and sends best wishes for his future endeavors.

Tuesday, May 7, 2013

Match Thoughts and Three Stars: RSL vs. Vancouver Whitecaps

Joao Plata was instrumental in RSL's attack on Saturday (Salt Lake Tribune)

I think I speak for a lot of Claret and Cobalt fans when I say "That's more like it!"  Even without talisman Alvaro Saborio, Real Salt Lake was able to step up and get great performances from a couple of different guys to pull out a 2-0 win over the Vancouver Whitecaps (or as section 35 put it the Flopcouver Divecaps) last Saturday night at Rio Tinto Stadium.

It's always a great feeling to walk away from Rio Tinto after three points have been earned, but this last week's match was critical, coach Jason Kreis said so himself.  I missed the team's lackluster match against L.A. home with strep throat, but after watching the match on replay, it was easy to see that RSL really needed to bounce back from that, especially in the first 15 minutes of the match.  Also on RSL's mind was the result from Vancouver a couple of weeks back when a questionable handball call on Nat Borchers cost them a potential three points on the road.

Of course Saturday night was not the all inclusive total 90 minute performance that coach Kreis has been looking for either.  While they did manage to keep Vancouver off the scoreboard, the first half was less than spectacular.  Few players in the Claret and Cobalt exhibited any decent touch on the ball, as even the midfielders seemed to come down with a case of the stone feet.  The passes were also uncharacteristically off.  The link up between the midfield and the forwards seemed to be especially off kilter.  A lot of the balls failed to connect, and when they did, neither Joao Plata nor Devon Sandoval seemed to be able to hold on to them.  This is somewhat understandable though.  Plata and Sandoval can't have spent a lot of time playing together or connecting with the starting guys in the midfield.  For Devon, it was also set to be his first 90 minute performance of his pro career.  As good as he's been this year, sometimes we forget that he is a rookie.

RSL cranked it up a notch during the second half though, and it was some of the best play I've seen from the team this year, especially on the counter attack.  Vancouver had shown their intention to come into Rio Tinto and play all night, and RSL took advantage right away in the second half.  In the 47th minute Nick Rimando triggered a counter with a goal kick, hitting Plata way up in the Vancouver half of the pitch.  Plata played a ball into the Vancouver box from the RSL right, where Luis Gil met it with his head to slot home and give RSL the 1-0 lead.  The goal is up for MLS goal of the week.

RSL caught Vancouver sleeping again in the 71st minute when sub Sebastian Velasquez used some of his nifty footwork to free himself from the defense.  He dropped of the ball to Plata. who again played the ball in from the right, this time to an onrushing Javier Morales, who dropped the ball into the near post corner to make it 2-0.  It was very impressive.  Somewhat less impressive was Vancouver's Gershon Koffie, who was supposedly marking Morales on the play.  He simply jogged back after the RSL man without a care in the world and rendered himself totally helpless once Morales had the pass at his feet.

Vancouver tried to make it interesting late on, but the RSL defense held firm, which brings us to our first ratings.  I thought the defense was pretty solid all the way around.  Beltran was active, and Borchers and Schuler always seemed to be where they needed to be to fend off a Vancouver attack.  Borchers' goal line clearance of a Vancouver shot was one of the plays of the night.  I spent a lot of time watching Schuler in the second half, as he was stationed right in front of me in section 30.  I thought his positioning was impeccable, and he rarely, if ever, looked flustered.  He also did a great job of hanging onto Vancouver's speedy Darren Mattocks when he came into the match in the second half.  Plus, how awesome was it to see Chris Wingert back in the side?  He really firmed up the defense on the left side.  My one mark down was that there were too many dangerous balls coming in from the Vancouver flanks.  I give the defense a B+.

The midfield really stepped up.  I thought Beckerman looked more involved than he has been of late, and Nedinho his just Nedinho, steady.  I know a lot of the fans would like to see the more flashy Velasquez start, but Ned brings that veteran presence and leadership that I think we need right now.  Of course, Gil and Morales stepped up to score the goals, which was huge with Sabo out.  The touch and link up play could have been better, so I'll give the midfield an A-.

Finally, the forwards.  In truth, it wasn't the best display, but both Plata and Sandoval improved over the course of the match.  Plata was the assist man, and he's been so instrumental in so many of our goals this year.  Sandoval really did well in the second half.  His touch improved light years from the first, and his holdup play was outstanding late on, giving RSL more of a shot at possession and chances.  Solid effort from both of those guys, so I'll say the forwards get a B.

So now I present to you the 3 stars for the Claret and Cobalt for Saturday, May 4 vs Vancouver.

3rd Star--Javier Morales.  Still the dynamo driving the RSL engine.
2nd Star--Nat Borchers.  His clearance off the line prevented a potentially game changing goal.
1st Star--Joao Plata.  His runs gave the 'Caps fits all night.  He assisted on both goals, making him the MLS assist leader going into Sunday morning.