Earlier in the year, US Soccer introduced some very nice changes to the Lamar Hunt US Open Cup. Among those changes was the addition of a regular draw procedure in some rounds instead of the past format where teams basically submitted bids to US Soccer for the rights to host these matches. This seemed like a positive change, and the people rejoiced!
Then last week after the second round results were complete, some things got stirred up again. Three time defending Champions Seattle Sounders announced that instead of playing the Atlanta Silverbacks in Atlanta as the draw had specified, they had purchased the rights to host the match in Washington, though not at Century Link. Many of us, including myself, took some not so polite jabs at our Sounders friends on twitter as it appeared they were once again trying to buy the US Open Cup and the accompanying birth in the CONCACAF Champions League.
Then some other information emerged. Turns out Portland Timbers had made an effort to buy their 3rd round game as well, however after Eric Wynalda's Cal FC emerged victorious, the match ended up being scheduled in Portland anyway. Ah, the shenanigans of those Cascadia teams!
Then something very interesting crossed the Real Salt Lake official Twitter feed. RSL was scheduled to play Minnesota Stars FC in Minnesota in the 3rd round. However, they also announced that they had purchased the rights to hold the match, and it is now scheduled to go down tonight at Rio Tinto Stadium. Turns out I had to eat my words to my Sounders friends.
It also turns out to be totally within the rules of the new format. Teams don't pay US Soccer for these matches anymore, but they can basically make an offer to the team drawn to host, and if the team accepts the offer, they can sell that right to the other team.
I call BS on that.
First off, let me say that I do understand why Seattle and RSL went this route. They want to win, and they want to do everything possible within the rules to make it happen. Both of these sides take the CONCACAF Champions League seriously and want to punch their tickets to next years tournament early. Plus, hey, it's hardware, and the awesome thing about soccer is that there is this chance to win multiple trophies. So, I've toned down my stance against the teams actually buying these matches. Suffice it to say, I'm still a bit cynical though.
You see, I'm a Eurosnob when it comes to footy. I admit that in the interest of full disclosure. I love the FA Cup, next to the UEFA Champions League, it's my favorite sporting event of the year. Part of the wonder of the FA Cup is the fact that later in the tournament, when the Championship and Premiership sides enter the fray, they may end up playing at some non-league ground somewhere. Some of the greatest upsets in the tournament's long and storied history have happened in these settings.
It's a treat to see these non league or lower league stadiums packed to the gills with their own fans, but also the traveling fans from the big clubs, who come into town spending money on food and perhaps lodging. I would love to see the US Open Cup go this direction: A total blind draw complete with the ping bong balls and the whole set up. Since we don't have a national stadium, I would advocate a 2-legged final much like they do with the Canadian Championship.
Let's be honest though. If RSL had played in Minnesota tonight, it's highly doubtful that RSL supporters would pack the Stars' ground like Manchester United supporters might pack a League 2 ground in England. It wouldn't be quite the same feel. However I believe that it would definitely be within the spirit of tournaments like this and promoting the lower leagues in the US Soccer Pyramid to have a draw and require the sides to stick to it. If a big MLS side has a problem with that, feel free not to enter.
I don't think that this will happen anytime soon. I really hope it does, because it's my personal opinion that allowing teams to buy matches cheapens a tournament of any kind. Sides like Real Salt Lake and Seattle usually hold a pretty tough home field advantage. I realize that in this case it was Atlanta and Minnesota's choice to go to these places and play, but again, I think it would be in the competitive interests of all the leagues to stick with the draw. It would also give the fans in other cities a chance to see MLS clubs play live which for the most part, can only be good for the sport.
Alas, soccer in the US doesn't appear to be at that point yet, though I hope it gets there someday soon. For tonight, I'll be at the RioT supporting my Real Salt Lake, even though I said I wouldn't in last week's twitter tantrum. I'm not happy with the rules, but I will still show up to support my team and hope that it changes in the future.